By LeiLani Cauthen
“We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them.” – Albert Einstein
Editor’s Note: This three-part series aims to identify the underlying problem to act on, rather than treating each challenge as isolated.
The Fall 2022 school year began amid a stark and visible teacher shortage. Districts across the country face a convergence of three major challenges: thousands of classrooms without certified teachers in large districts; significant student attrition to alternative education options; and a decline in student achievement following the pandemic.
Policy responses have tended to repeat familiar prescriptions: more funding, expanded recruitment (including international hiring), increased use of tutoring services, charter growth, and relaxed certification pathways. Some proposals have even suggested unconventional measures such as accelerated certificates for high school graduates or using state resources in novel ways. But if policymakers are not addressing the true root causes, these measures risk being insufficient or even counterproductive.
To understand the crisis, we must examine the supply and decision chains that lead to teacher hiring and retention, inspect how different levers affect the system, and look beyond conventional assumptions about what the problem actually is. The teacher shortage has been growing for years; the pandemic amplified it, but it did not create it from scratch.
The Salary Issue
Public discussion often frames pay as the central cause of teacher shortages. Decades of messaging have suggested teachers are underpaid, but a deeper look shows the picture is more complex. Many teachers receive generous benefits: defined-benefit pensions, employer-paid health coverage, and relatively stable employment. These total compensation packages can significantly raise the overall value of a teacher’s pay compared with many private-sector jobs.
That said, rising cost pressures—especially health care inflation and recent spikes in the cost of living—make additional pay and cost-of-living adjustments sensible. But the wider compensation story matters: when pensions and benefits are included, the total “all-in” value of many teacher positions can approximate six figures, especially when factoring in health care, retirement benefits, and time off.
Public claims about teachers paying out-of-pocket for classroom supplies resonate emotionally, but similar out-of-pocket expenses exist in many professions (uniforms, tools, equipment). The more telling issue is the perception of the profession. If students do not view teachers as inspiring or effective role models from their years in school, fewer will choose teaching as a career. Compensation alone is rarely the primary deterrent; job design, prestige, work conditions, and the inspiration factor matter greatly.
The Retirement Issue
Retirements among Baby Boomers have significantly reduced the teacher workforce. Surveys and labor statistics show a large share of educators considering early retirement, and many Boomer-aged staff have already left the profession. This wave of retirements contributes to sustained openings even as fewer new teachers enter training programs. In 2021, the number of college students preparing to teach was far below projected replacement needs.
Population cohorts after Gen X—Millennials and Gen Z—are large enough to replace retirements, but they are not entering teaching in present numbers. Part of the reason is the profession’s perceived lack of attractiveness: high stress, heavy reporting burdens, classroom management challenges, and the mismatch between the reality of modern teaching and the ideal many younger adults imagine. The “great resignation” is therefore less a cause than a symptom of deeper, structural issues within the job itself.
The Changing Student Body
Student demographics have shifted rapidly in recent years. Pre-pandemic public enrollment was over 56 million students served by roughly 3.3 million teachers. Homeschooling increased notably during the pandemic, and private and public patterns have shifted as well. At the same time, recent immigration has added millions of children to public school rolls without a corresponding rise in teachers trained to meet diverse cultural and linguistic needs.
Schools historically served as cultural “norming” institutions, but today’s schools face a vastly more multicultural student population with a wide range of needs, norms, languages, and expectations. These shifts place new demands on curriculum design, language instruction, special education, and classroom management. As student populations diversify, the one-size-fits-all model of instruction struggles to keep pace, and schools are pressured to adopt alternatives or accommodations that further complicate staffing and instructional design.
In short, the changing student body intensifies the demands on teachers and on school systems, contributing to burnout and departures. But like retirements and pay debates, this is a factor in a larger, interconnected problem rather than the single root cause.
Other Indicators That the Shortage Is Not the Whole Problem
- High burnout: Large surveys found many teachers reporting overwhelming stress and burnout—symptoms of a job that has been reshaped by accountability demands, technology adoption, and pandemic pressures.
- Declining achievement: Student achievement declined nationally, with significant learning loss tied to intermittent closures and inconsistent in-person attendance. This suggests the need to reexamine learning models and the structure of instruction, not just teacher numbers.
- Shifting markets for digital learning: Consumer demand for digital curriculum and education apps now exceeds school spending, indicating growing confidence in professional-grade, low-human-intervention learning tools. This points to opportunities in better-designed digital curriculum and workflow that reduce teacher burdens.
- Fragmented tech adoption: Schools often adopt a large number of digital tools without a coherent curricular strategy, leaving teachers juggling dozens or hundreds of resources. This adds to workload and reduces the effectiveness of technology investments.
These signals point to a deeper reality: teachers remain vital, but the design of the job, the structure of schools, and the way technology and curriculum are organized require systemic redesign. More bodies in classrooms will not solve the root problems if the work remains fragmented, overwhelming, and misaligned with modern demands.
The teacher shortage is not the core problem. It is an urgent symptom of broader structural issues: job and workflow design, changing student needs, cultural shifts, and outdated instructional models. Addressing those deeper challenges—reimagining the role of human teachers, deploying professional-grade digital curriculum, and redesigning school logistics—offers a path to sustained improvement in recruitment, retention, and student outcomes.
Stay tuned for more in this series:
Part 2: The Attrition Issue
Part 3: The Achievement Issue
About the Author
LeiLani Cauthen is CEO and Publisher of The Learning Counsel. She specializes in digital content, software development, adoption processes, and the transformation of teaching and learning in the 21st century. With two decades of research, publishing, and market leadership across high tech, education, and government sectors, she is a recognized author and media commentator in the field.
References:
- Garcia, Emma and Elaine Weiss. “The teacher shortage is real, large and growing, and worse than we thought.” Economic Policy Institute, March 26, 2019.
- OPERS. Traditional Pension Plan overview: defined benefit retirement programs.
- SWFI. Top 100 Largest Corporate Pension Rankings by Total Assets.
- Josephson, Amelia. “Pension Plans: Definition, Types, Benefits & Risks.” SmartAsset, Aug 30, 2022.
- U.S. Chamber of Commerce. “The State of Small Business Now,” Sept. 16, 2021.
- KFF. Percent of private sector establishments offering health insurance by firm size, 2020.
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Establishments with fewer than 50 workers, March 2017.
- TradingEconomics. United States Employed Persons, Aug. 2022.
- Weissmann, Jordan. “Are Teachers Paid Too Much? How 4 Studies Answered 1 Big Question.” The Atlantic, Nov. 4, 2011.
- Biggs, Andrew G. and Jason Richwine. “Average Public School Teacher Is Paid Too Much.” U.S. News & World Report, Nov. 9, 2011.
- Indeed. “What’s the Average Salary in the U.S.?” June 30, 2022.
- HealthMarkets. “How Much Does Health Insurance Cost Per Month?” 2022.
- Silcox, Fallon. “Teachers across the country are quitting and changing careers,” March 9, 2022.
- Forbes Finance Council. “Retirement Trends Of Baby Boomers,” David Haass, Sept. 3, 2019.
- Pew Research Center. “The pace of Boomer retirements has accelerated,” Nov. 9, 2020.
- CNN. “The data that shows Boomers are to blame for the labor shortage,” Allison Morrow, Dec. 18, 2021.
- Camarota, Steven A., and Karen Zeigler. “Foreign-Born Population Hits Record 46.6 Million in January 2022.” February 23, 2022.
- Child Trends. “Immigrant Children,” Dec. 28, 2018.
- FAIR Analysis. “4.9 Million Illegal Aliens Have Crossed our Borders Since President Biden Took Office,” Aug. 16, 2022.
- Migration Policy Institute. Annual number of U.S. legal permanent residents.
- Migration Policy Institute. Frequently requested statistics on immigrants and immigration in the United States.
- Center for Generational Kinetics. “How Large is Each Generation in the US?”